Better title would be "make swords the primary weapon again" because of 8 failed sieges due to piss poor farmers given pew pew sticks

To the 1. Nerf I agree you shouldn't be able to aim accurate while moving.
To the 2. Nerf/feature I would say that carbines should be unaffected to it to because they are for close range so only rifles and mgs will be disabled
To the nerfs 3 and 4 I don't really have an opinion

basically u want to make guns sidearms again, no thanks

This seems a lot more reasonable also Dom_Innovation he is GNE, and they haven't lost a lot of sieges recently

"make guns trash again"

No.

The funniest part is calling machine guns and pistols "Overpowered" seemingly without realizing swords are all that's being used in close combat. Maybe we should nerf swords?

"This seems a lot more reasonable also Dom_Innovation he is GNE, and they haven't lost a lot of sieges recently"
id rather stick with a nation that actually helps the towns it has than to stick with a military dictatorship in minecraft quit eating away at the propaganda coalition throws at you to consume peasant your only argument is that im in GNE my town used to be in thracia and it was backwards until i joined GNE

I'm not even gonna bother arguing with people who don't have any particular arguments just think as long as guns are not overpowered and start taking a little bit of skill, they become "trash" and "side-arms", like genuinely not good arguments. Rattly you just want GNE to win because GNE has been winning all sieges recently with guns.

Rattly has 0 regard for actual balanced gameplay or a situation where people have fun

??? im having fun even at 200ms.
Fun is subjective, just because you find something different to be fun does not mean almost everyone else does.
Also gun damage tick delay exists now I see no need for nerfs except maybe the second point and thats to make the sidearms actually more viable in combat

The pistol nerf in this suggestion is bs the whole point of pistols is to give balance in close combat. A sword is STILL better than a pistol on close combat and thats a fact. I think pistols should become slightly more accurate and the 3 block bug be removed

Cuz the fire spread of pistols is so random half the shots go wide

Also carbines and guns with bayonet shouldnt be combat disabled by sword hit

Berry speaking facts
What's the point of a sidearm?

If it's introduced to balance out swords in close combat, why do you feel the need to:
1) Make their accuracy trash while moving (are we supposed to stand still?)
2) Reduce their fire rate (a full magazine can't kill a single person) now include reload time and your odds are at 0.

There's a reason you see 0 machine gun kills in a heavy siege, there's a reason you see a dozen sidearm kills at a siege and there's a reason you see 100 sword kills at a siege. Guns are not overpowered in the slightest when it comes to close combat.

guns should be inaccurate while moving, except for carbines and pistol, it was a right move to have a damage delay of 0.5 so that damages won't stack and 1 tap players, this is a already satisfying nerf anymore nerfs would be unneeded and anymore buffs would be overpowered. guns and swords have their own purpose, a gun is more long range, a sword is for close range, and swords already disable guns when hit, so I don't see the reason sword mains crying being 1 tapped when it's their fault for walking in front of the open without realized guns are a threat. swords will always be better than guns, even if guns have an advantage in range anyway, you just have to play around with your environment and movement (no see no shoot)

it's no reason to cry over gun spammers too, it's all just the matter if you're more or less than what the enemy has. people cry when there's too many sword players on the other group, and it's the same when it happens to guns, you would be so smart if you think walking towards 10 people with just a sword would be a good idea, just as if you walk with a gun infront of 10 pvpiers.

Fram where did u get your stats from??
Sidearms can delete people, swords do kills mostly when the enemy has been double headshotted or in ganks, and machineguns get plenty of kills or are a big contributor

"and swords already disable guns when hit" no they dont solaris, thats why it should be added so people actually use sidearms instead of machine gun spamming you point blank
also if you let someone get near to you, realistically the sword/close combat weapon should win , its only balanced

"swords will always be better than guns" actually fake, rn they are not, sidearms and machineguns exist

>Fram where did u get your stats from??
I use the search filter on the Discord Nation channel. It shows me next to nobody died to machineguns, around a dozen died to sidearms, then rifles and the crown is taken by swords.

The 1911 has 7 rounds and does 1 heart per direct hit, you can do the maths on that. Headshot damages are not listed on sidearms.

Guns are meant to be the main weapon cope.

I use the search filter too and I have actually fought in the frontlines