I like this as well. I would also add that there should be a different kind of ping sound when you hit a friendly rather than an enemy to alert you of your mistake.

ijust woke up and chose thousands of newbies to get their ear blown up buy their teammate after friendlyfire.

"u dont even need position or aim"

As a person who actively shoots people and that is annoying to enemies because of that, I can confirm that position and aim is very important. The only part of the gunning you feel is when I hit you 10 times in a row while you are alone far from banner. Most of the times its 50/50 if you can land a shot at people in the banner cause you have no idea where they are and even when you know you still need good aim for that

Before it got added that gun projectile passes through allies you almost never landed shots, maybe like 1 out of 10, hitting allies would make guns unusable

Position wise I had to legit run from side to side to get a good angle and was swapping places often since not all angles are the same and not all angles are easy to hit enemies. You saw where I had to stand often to actually have a good chance to land hits. Its legit so close to enemy ganks that I often had to check all my sides to not get flanked. It was very much risky and I did die due to holes on my run back. Sometimes you deal damage sometimes you dont. Enemies also have 50/50 chance that they either heal by food or by pots. The people that dont do what I do I have no idea how many shots they land, maybe they can share that info with us

I legit had to sit in aimlab as much as anyone else who does sword pvp to hit that many times consistently. Ill be more than happy to track my statistics next war to check how much damage im doing per session and you can track yours and we can compare to see if guns are busted or not. Not to mention I sometimes focus you for the whole fight if
I can find you in the fight so the pov might not be that accurate on average

overall I'm not saying guns should be op or better than swords but there should be some statistics behind the suggestion that back it up to why they are too strong. Safety is one thing but you are trading doing less damage than sword for that safety. You can also just ride down on a horse into gunners to push them off (if they are attacker) which also happened multiple times and prevented people from using guns, but as far as defender gunners go you kind of need snipers to shoot them back