i think the loyalty system was a great addition to the server and should be added back, the main reason for that is the fact that the loyalty system rewards the players that invest time and only have time to play ccnet rather than multiple servers at once. When a nation gathers 20 people from various servers who dont know what they're doing or why they are there and the only thing that they've been told is to kill the red tag players and then we remove the loyalty system thats when we start to punish the people who only have time to play ccnet.
Another big reason and something we all suffer from are the queue's. if we add the loyalty system we will prevent a horde of random players who will not play the server again after that particular siege week we would have much less queue waiting time on the weekends.